| Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | |||
| No. 16 Mount Union | 63 | No. 1 Thomas More | 76 | Final | RC RC | |
| Eastern Connecticut | 54 | No. 2 Amherst | 76 | Final | ||
| Simpson | 75 | No. 3 UW-Stevens Point | 82 | Final | RC RC | |
| No. 12 Washington U. | 56 | No. 4 Hope | 52 | Final | RC | |
| No. 5 Babson | 65 | SUNY Geneseo | 53 | Final | RC | |
| No. 6 Chicago | 67 | No. 18 Calvin | 62 | Final | RC RC | |
| Wisconsin Lutheran | 69 | No. 7 Illinois Wesleyan | 84 | Final | RC RC | |
| Western Connecticut | 64 | No. 9 Kean | 82 | Final | RC | |
| Johns Hopkins | 62 | No. 11 Christopher Newport | 81 | Final | RC | |
| Muhlenberg | 74 | No. 13 Rochester | 69 | Final | RC | |
| No. 15 Greensboro | 57 | Juniata | 55 | Final | RC | |
| Randolph-Macon | 56 | No. 17 Lebanon Valley | 73 | Final | RC | |
| Colby | 53 | No. 19 William Paterson | 58 | Final | RC | |
| No. 21 Louisiana College | 47 | George Fox | 63 | Final | RC | |
| No. 22 Mount St. Mary | 53 | Bowdoin | 61 | Final | RC | |
| Howard Payne | 56 | No. 23 Coe | 79 | Final | RC | |