| Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | |||
| No. 1 Whitworth | 85 | Pacific Lutheran | 59 | Final | • * | RC |
| No. 2 Middlebury | 74 | Bowdoin | 59 | Final | • * | |
| No. 4 Williams | 79 | Colby | 50 | Final | • * | |
| No. 19 Wabash | 69 | No. 5 Wooster | 68 | Final - OT | • * | RC RC |
| Washington and Lee | 41 | No. 6 Randolph-Macon | 72 | Final | • * | |
| Carthage | 65 | No. 7 Augustana | 58 | Final | • * | RC |
| Bates | 68 | No. 9 Amherst | 74 | Final | • * | |
| Roanoke | 60 | No. 10 Virginia Wesleyan | 92 | Final | • * | RC |
| Ohio Northern | 58 | No. 11 Marietta | 68 | Final | • * | RC |
| La Sierra | 64 | No. 12 Chapman | 86 | Final | ||
| Marymount | 52 | No. 13 St. Mary's (Md.) | 82 | Final | • * | RC |
| No. 14 WPI | 78 | Wheaton (Mass.) | 46 | Final | • * | RC RC |
| No. 16 St. Norbert | 65 | Grinnell | 79 | Final | • * | RC RC |
| D'Youville | 54 | No. 20 La Roche | 64 | Final | • * | |
| Rose-Hulman | 59 | No. 21 Manchester | 67 | Final | • * | |
| UW-Whitewater | 70 | No. 22 UW-River Falls | 66 | Final | • * | RC |
| No. 23 Western Connecticut | 87 | Plymouth State | 69 | Final | • * | |
| DePauw | 65 | No. 25 Centre | 63 | Final | • * | RC |
| Becker | 72 | Wheelock | 70 | Final | • * | RC |
| Husson | 84 | Lyndon St. | 86 | Final | • * | |
| Johnson and Wales | 92 | Lasell | 86 | Final | • * | |
| Colby-Sawyer | 66 | Salve Regina | 73 | Final | • * | RC |
| Bethany | 59 | Grove City | 43 | Final | • * | |
| New Jersey City | 64 | Brooklyn | 48 | Final | • | RC RC |
| SUNYIT | 84 | Wells | 86 | Final | • * | |
| Hanover | 83 | Bluffton | 76 | Final | • * | |
| Bridgewater State | 87 | Fitchburg State | 54 | Final | • * | |
| Rhode Island College | 78 | Keene State | 69 | Final | • * | RC |
| Cabrini | 92 | Clarks Summit | 81 | Final | • * | |
| Hartwick | 68 | Alfred | 70 | Final | • * | RC |
| Catholic | 64 | Scranton | 79 | Final | • * | RC RC |
| N.C. Wesleyan | 70 | Christopher Newport | 68 | Final | • * | |
| Gwynedd-Mercy | 88 | Neumann | 85 | Final | • * | |
| SUNY New Paltz | 79 | Buffalo State | 89 | Final | • * | |
| Utica | 94 | Ithaca | 89 | Final | • * | |
| Newbury | 73 | Elms | 84 | Final | • * | RC |
| Penn State-Behrend | 67 | Pitt-Greensburg | 65 | Final | • * | |
| Sul Ross State | 70 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 75 | Final | • * | |
| Texas-Dallas | 73 | East Texas Baptist | 70 | Final | • * | RC |
| McMurry | 68 | Schreiner | 67 | Final | • * | |
| MacMurray | 67 | Webster | 75 | Final | • * | |
| Luther | 68 | Central | 51 | Final | • * | RC |
| MSOE | 86 | Wisconsin Lutheran | 72 | Final | • * | |
| Lakeland | 82 | Benedictine | 87 | Final | • * | |
| Allegheny | 60 | Wittenberg | 90 | Final | • * | RC |
| Northwestern (Minn.) | 81 | Northland | 58 | Final | • * | |
| Montclair State | 68 | Ramapo | 78 | Final | • * | RC |
| Alvernia | 58 | Messiah | 54 | Final | • * | RC |
| Hope | 85 | Alma | 71 | Final | • * | |
| Hobart | 75 | Skidmore | 66 | Final | • * | RC |
| Concordia-Chicago | 70 | Maranatha Baptist | 57 | Final | • * | |
| Caltech | 67 | Redlands | 75 | Final | • * | RC |