| Away | Home | Time/Status | Links | |||
| No. 2 Middlebury | 80 | Colby-Sawyer | 54 | Final | • | |
| Lancaster Bible | 51 | No. 18 Franklin and Marshall | 109 | Final | • | RC |
| Johnson and Wales | 89 | Connecticut College | 83 | Final | • | |
| Mount St. Vincent | 64 | SUNY-Purchase | 91 | Final | • * | RC |
| Colby | 75 | Husson | 70 | Final | • | |
| Becker | 65 | Western New England | 63 | Final | • | RC |
| Grove City | 50 | Bethany | 75 | Final | • * | |
| University of the Ozarks | 57 | Mary Hardin-Baylor | 68 | Final | • * | |
| Texas-Dallas | 101 | Concordia (Texas) | 74 | Final | • * | |
| Mississippi College | 64 | McMurry | 77 | Final | • * | RC |
| Principia | 52 | Webster | 85 | Final | • * | |